Protein Ice Cream does NOT have to be boring! This Cake Batter Protein CREAMi recipe is a burst of delicious flavor and is just as low calorie and high protein as all my other protein CREAMi recipes!

Jump to Recipe

Want to save this post?

Enter your email below and get it sent straight to your inbox.

The inside “scoop” on this Cake Batter Protein CREAMi

These recipes are from Clean Simple Eats, but I made one change to ALL of them. They have you adding 2 tablespoons milk on a re-spin to get the ice cream creamy, but you don’t have to do that if you put your ice cream on the counter for 15 minutes. It’s smooth and creamy EVERY TIME on my FIRST spin. If it’s crumbly, you can add more liquid, but that also means it wasn’t thawed enough (My ICE CREAM EXPERT OPINION!!)

If you want to grab any Clean Simple Eats Protein powder, my discount code is HEALTHBEET

Ingredients for THE BEST Cake Batter Protein Ice Cream

2% Milk – If you’ve ever made Ninja CREAMi ice cream, you know the drill! Milk is the BASE of this recipe!
Cake Batter Protein Powder – This is not the most common flavor so you might not have it on hand! I got mine from Clean Simple Eats and it was perfect! If you are looking to buy some, use my discount code HEALTHBEET at checkout!
Vanilla Sandwich Cookies – I used Oreo brand but any vanilla cookies will work! This just adds delicious crunch!
Rainbow Sprinkles – Because what is cake batter without the sprinkles?!

Other Protein CREAMi Recipes

If you like this recipe, you’ll love some of the other CREAMi recipes I have been posting! Here are my top 3!